Raymond Albert Gardner

Search for a person, place, crime or information

Receive updates by email

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Random Listings

  • Tjeerd Visser
    Published on NZ Herald 27 Sept 2012 https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10836941 Farmer sentenced for starving cows A West Coast farmer has been sentenced to community service after 60 cattle were found dead and dying. Tjeerd Visser, 24, was sentenced in Christchurch District CourtRead …
  • Steven John Wells
    Updated from the original article below. Published on TVNZ website May 11 2018 https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/new-zealand/golden-bay-farmer-hit-cows-pipe-and-slammed-gate-into-one-their-heads-banned-owning-animals-five-years   A Golden Bay farmer who broke the tails of several cows, hit them with a polythene pipe and kicked one of his herd in theRead …
  • David and Daryl Balfour
    Published in the New Zealand Herald 29 June 2012. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10816429   A former New Zealand Kennel Club dog-show judge and his wife have been banned from owning or caring for animals for 20 years. David and Daryl Balfour were eachRead …
sad dog

Archives


Published on stuff.co.nz 22/06/2018

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/104920012/nelson-farmer-banned-for-illtreatment-of-dead-rotting-and-dying-calves

A Nelson judge found himself in a “very difficult position” when finding an appropriate sentence for a 77-year-old Richmond farmer charged with animal cruelty.

Inspections of a Redwood Valley beef farm belonging to Raymond Albert Gardner, 77, uncovered dead, rotting, and dying calves, cows in “obvious pain and distress” with skin sores and diarrhoea, and cattle housed in a shed that was a “deep boggy mix of sawdust, mud, water and effluent”.

Gardner was sentenced in the Nelson District Court on Friday on three charges of failing to provide treatment to ill and injured animals, three of failing to meet animals’ needs, three of keeping a suffering animal alive, and two of ill-treating an animal.

Judge David Ruth said at sentencing it was “serious-end offending”, but the court had found itself in a difficult position determining a suitable sentence.

“If he was a younger man he’d go to jail … because of his age and circumstances imprisonment would be quite inappropriate and so home detention is also out of the equation.”

In a some instances he thought calves in his care had already died – one “moribund” calf was outside the pens, half buried in mud and Gardner told inspectors it was dead; it was found to be still breathing.

A further nine calves were found dead, and Gardner said they’d died from scours as he’d been feeding them a mix of lamb’s milk powder and green-top milk as he hadn’t been able to get calf milk powder.

One calf was found alive but “collapsed”, “emaciated” and “flyblown” with mature maggots and new eggs, and had to be euthanised immediately by a vet.

Despite being given a treatment plan involving electrolytes and proper feeding regime, over the course of months Gardner failed to improve the conditions on the farm, and was charged with animal cruelty.

In sentencing, Judge Ruth said Gardner couldn’t do community work, due again to his age and personal circumstances.

He agreed with Ministry of Primary Industries lawyer Julie Wotton’s calculations for an appropriate fine, which had a starting point of more than $50,000.

However, even if he applied generous, but feasible, discounts based on personal circumstances and guilty pleas, it would still be more than $20,000 – “out of the question” in terms of what Gardner’s assets and finances.

Judge Ruth was aware Gardner had suffered a serious injury and it appeared that had affected his ability to manage animals.

“Otherwise, simply on the face of it, the evidence before me would indicate totally callous and cruel behaviour, otherwise inexplicable.”