Published in the New Zealand Herald 28/07/2016
The slaughterman whose cruel mistreatment of bobby calves was caught on camera has been sentenced to home detention.
Noel Erickson, 38, has escaped a jail term but was sentenced in the Huntly District Court today to 10 months home detention and 200 hours community work.
Judge Merelina Burnett called the mistreatment, which involved the kicking, hitting and throwing of bobby calves, as “outside the job description” of Erickson, who was a casual slaughterman at pet food business Down Cow, near Te Kauwhata, in August last year when he was secretly filmed by Farmwatch New Zealand.
Erickson had earlier pleaded guilty to 10 charges including two of wilfully ill-treating a calf, recklessly ill-treating calves and using blunt force trauma.
The court heard how Erickson, who was emotional in the dock, dragged, hit, kicked and threw 115 bobby calves over two days at Down Cow.
Judge Burnett said the calves were vulnerable because they were newborns.
They were meant to be stunned and then killed but one was hung on a meat hook still alive.
Others were thrown or kicked with such force it would have caused pain and suffering, she said.
Erickson’s lawyer said his client was not given sufficient instruction and felt he could not disobey his employers because he was struggling to support his wife and 4-year-old daughter.
Judge Burnett accepted Erickson was not adequately trained or supervised.
“It would be nice to be in a society where young and vulnerable animals like this were not treated in this fashion.”
Outside the court animal activist Lynley Tulloch, who operates a bobby calf rescue programme, said the sentence was weak.
“This was a landmark case and it demonstrates New Zealand’s lack of commitment to animal welfare.”
Save Animals From Exploitation executive director Hans Kriek said the sentence was finally justice for the abused calves.
However, he said SAFE remained concerned not enough was being done to protect the welfare of millions of calves born into the dairy industry each year.
Around two million calves were surplus to requirements each year.
The abuse was brought to light after Farmwatch secretly filmed Erickson in a hidden camera sting.
The Ministry for Primary Industries launched a probe last September following release of the footage.